Liability and malpractice
3 free Uniform MPJE practice questions on this topic, with the answer, a reason for every option and the source. The full bank has 20 questions here.
Malpractice by a pharmacist is best described as:
- Aa criminal offense defined by the Controlled Substances Act
- Bany violation of a board of pharmacy record-keeping rule
- Cprofessional negligence that causes harm to a patient
Show answer and sources
Answer: C. professional negligence that causes harm to a patient
Malpractice, or professional negligence, is a tort committed when a professional breaches a duty to a client or patient and the breach causes injury (Cornell LII Wex, Malpractice; PMC2628513).
- A. Incorrect: malpractice is a civil tort, not a federal crime.
- B. Incorrect: a rule violation is an administrative matter and is not malpractice by itself.
- C. Correct: malpractice is professional negligence, a breach of a professional's duty that causes harm.
To win a professional negligence (malpractice) lawsuit against a pharmacist, the patient must prove:
- Abreach of duty, causation, damages and a crime
- Bduty, intent to harm, breach of duty and damages
- Cduty, a breach of duty, causation and damages
Show answer and sources
Answer: C. duty, a breach of duty, causation and damages
A malpractice plaintiff must prove a professional duty owed to the patient, breach of that duty, injury caused by the breach, and resulting damages (PMC2628513; PMC3088386).
- A. Incorrect: a criminal violation is not an element of a civil negligence claim.
- B. Incorrect: negligence does not require intent to harm.
- C. Correct: these are the four elements of a malpractice claim.
A pharmacist correctly dispenses and labels a prescribed drug, and an expert agrees that everything the pharmacist did met the standard of care. The patient still has a poor treatment outcome and sues. On the question of breach, the patient will most likely:
- Asucceed, because dispensing the drug makes the pharmacist liable
- Bfail, because a bad outcome alone does not show a breach
- Csucceed, because any poor outcome shows a breach of duty
Show answer and sources
Answer: B. fail, because a bad outcome alone does not show a breach
In malpractice cases, breach of duty is measured against the standard of care, meaning what a reasonable, similarly situated professional would have done (PMC3088386; PMC2628513).
- A. Incorrect: dispensing a drug does not by itself create liability.
- B. Correct: breach is measured against the standard of care, which the pharmacist met.
- C. Incorrect: an outcome alone does not establish breach of the standard of care.
- [1] Moffett P, Moore G. The Standard of Care: Legal History and Definitions. West J Emerg Med. 2011 (PMC3088386) . Legal definitions
- [2] Bal BS. An Introduction to Medical Malpractice in the United States. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2009 (PMC2628513) . Breach
- [3] Cornell LII Wex: standard of care . Standard of care
Practise all 20 questions on this topic
Tutor mode, timed blocks and progress tracking.